How Local Businesses Can Show Up On ChatGPT

Local SEO has always required businesses to adapt, but the latest curveball is a big one. ChatGPT and other generative AI tools are changing how people discover local services. Instead of opening Google and scrolling through a list of links, more users are simply asking a tool like ChatGPT where to go—and trusting the answer.

This shift is subtle but important. If you’re not adjusting your visibility strategy to account for AI-driven search, you could be missing out on potential customers who never make it to a search engine results page.

Here’s how ChatGPT is shaping local search—and what you can do to keep showing up.

Let’s Start with What ChatGPT Actually Is

ChatGPT is not a search engine. It’s an AI assistant trained on massive amounts of text data, designed to answer questions, summarize information, and have conversations. It doesn’t crawl the web in real time the way Google does. Instead, when a user asks for local recommendations, ChatGPT relies on:

• Built-in training data (frozen in time, unless browsing is enabled)
• Third-party sources like Bing, Yelp, TripAdvisor, or Google Business profiles
• Plug-ins and custom GPTs that enhance its access to current data

So when a user says, “Find me a good dog groomer near Capitol Hill,” ChatGPT pulls together info from sources it considers reliable and current. If your business isn’t present or properly optimized on those sources, it simply won’t show up.

Step 1: Prioritize Directory Listings

Most local businesses have already claimed their Google Business Profile. But if that’s the only platform where your business is listed, that’s a problem.

You need to be just as visible across other data sources ChatGPT might pull from:

• Bing Places: Microsoft’s version of Google Business Profile, and key to being visible in Bing search—which ChatGPT uses heavily
• Yelp: Still a major player in local reviews and a top integration for AI tools
• Apple Maps, TripAdvisor, Yellow Pages, Foursquare, and Facebook: Yes, even Facebook’s About section can help strengthen your online footprint

Check for consistency. Your business name, address, phone number, hours, and services should match across every platform. Inconsistent listings confuse AI tools and lower trust signals. 

Step 2: Reviews Are More Than Just Reputation

Customer reviews have always influenced decision-making. Now, they also influence what AI tools choose to surface.

When ChatGPT provides local recommendations, it often mentions “highly rated” or “top-reviewed” businesses. That’s not accidental. Tools like Yelp and Google Reviews provide structured data—average rating, total number of reviews, and keywords from customer comments—that AI tools can easily digest.

Here’s how to make the most of reviews:

• Ask for them consistently after a purchase or service
• Respond to reviews—both good and bad—with natural, helpful replies
• Highlight standout reviews on your site and social channels

Avoid short, canned responses like “Thanks for the feedback!” They don’t add value for real users or AI models interpreting sentiment.

Step 3: Structured Website Content Still Matters

Even though ChatGPT leans heavily on third-party platforms, your website is still an important source of truth. But it needs to be easy for machines to understand.

Use structured data (also called schema markup) to clearly identify:

• Your business name and type
• Address and contact info
• Hours of operation
• Reviews and ratings
• Areas you serve

You don’t need to do this manually—there are tools and plugins for WordPress, Shopify, and other platforms that can help. Or, work with an SEO partner to make sure your structured data is set up correctly.

Beyond technical setup, make sure your content is human-friendly too. Use neighborhood names, landmarks, and locally relevant language to help reinforce your location.

Step 4: Optimize for Natural, Conversational Search

The way people search through ChatGPT is different. Instead of short keywords, they ask full questions:

• “Where can I get my phone screen fixed in Georgetown?”
• “What’s a good brunch spot near Dupont Circle that takes reservations?”
• “Who’s the best contractor in Alexandria for basement waterproofing?”

To meet those needs, your website should include content that answers real-world, conversational questions. Some easy wins:

• Create an FAQ page with local queries
• Add blog posts about services by neighborhood
• Highlight unique offerings like same-day service, family-friendly options, or pet access

The more your site mirrors how people actually speak and ask questions, the better chance you have of being referenced by AI tools.

Step 5: Don’t Ignore Bing

Yes, we said Bing.

It might not have the cultural weight of Google, but Bing is the default search engine behind ChatGPT and Microsoft’s Copilot tools. If ChatGPT is using Bing’s index to find your business, then you need to show up well there too.

That means:

• Claiming and optimizing your Bing Places listing
• Getting backlinks from high-authority sites
• Making sure your site is mobile-friendly and fast

You can even test how your business appears in Bing by searching your name and services manually. If the results are outdated or underwhelming, your AI visibility probably is too.

Final Thought: The Search Game Is Changing

This isn’t just a trend. AI-assisted search is here to stay, and it’s already changing the customer journey—especially for local businesses. People trust the recommendations ChatGPT gives them. They’re acting on those recommendations. If your business isn’t showing up there, it’s not because you’re doing anything wrong. It’s because the rules have changed.

At PBJ Marketing, we’re helping businesses rethink their local SEO strategy with AI in mind. If you’re curious how visible your business is in AI-powered tools—or what needs fixing—we’d be happy to take a look.

No jargon, no pressure. Just practical advice to help you stay ahead.

‍